Tablet magazine announced in a blog post yesterday that they’ll be taking an unusual step to deal with sometimes unruly commenters: charging readers who want to submit — or even view — comments on their site.

https://twitter.com/SusanElizabeth/status/564863389076168704

Editor Alana Newhouse wrote that the new talk-back charge is aimed at heightening the discourse on the website.

We take pride in our community of readers, and are thrilled that you choose to engage with us in a way that is both thoughtful and thought-provoking. But the Internet, for all of its wonders, poses challenges to civilized and constructive discussion, sometimes allowing destructive — and, often, anonymous — individuals to drag it down with invective (and worse). Instead of shutting off comments altogether (as some outlets are starting to do), we are going to try something else: Ask those of you who’d like to comment on the site to pay a nominal fee — less a paywall than a gesture of your own commitment to the cause of great conversation.

To make the paid commenting system possible, Tablet called upon the services of Tinypass, a popular third-party paywall company. Tinypass chief strategy officer David Restrepo says out of hundreds of publisher clients, Tablet is the only one using the software in this way. “TabletMag is the first publisher to use Tinypass for a comments paywall,” he says. Tinypass’s flexible API made it relatively simple to build a platform for paid comments. (Tablet was previously using Facebook’s comment platform.)

For all the various ways publishers have tried to improve their comment sections, few have taken a step as large as charging readers.

Don't ban comments, just make people pay a fee to make them. Cash for comments. *bows, exits left*

— Brendan O'Connor (@_grendan) November 19, 2013

Putting up another barrier — one that necessitates a credit card, or at least a PayPal account — aims to disincentivize individuals whose only motivation is trolling from joining the conversation. The group blog Metafilter is one of the few to try a version of this model: Its members make a single payment of $5 for the ability to share links and comment on the site; reading remains free. The website says this system helps ensure trust in the community and that the quality of contributions is high. The comedy website Something Awful has a similar system, charging a one-time $10 fee for posting and reading access to its forums.

The Metafilter model comes to a news organization. http://t.co/rsl51MgSyw via @ericspiegelman

— Philip Bump (@pbump) February 9, 2015

In November, popular humor and commentary website The Toast started offering subscriptions to its not-as-yet-launched chat feature which will include “invitations to chats with our authors and contributors.” Since The Toast has open comments, their chat feature is more likely aimed at revenue building, however, whereas Tablet’s new comments paywall is more about improving the quality of conversation.

Talking Points Memo, a similarly reader-driven site born in the age of the blog now offers The Hive, a members-only chat room, as part of its Prime package. The promise of The Hive? “No trolls. No screaming.” TPM founder Josh Marshall says he thinks paid commenting makes a lot of sense.

“Creating small barriers to entry for comments — enough to ward off drive-bys but not a problem for more dedicated readers — can make all the difference in the world,” he says. “And it’s made a world of difference in The Hive.”

Newhouse is right in saying that, lately, many websites have decided to deal with the troll problem by shutting down comments completely. Bloomberg became the latest to follow the trend with the launch of their new Bloomberg Business website. In an interview, editor Joshua Topolsky told me that other news outlets closing their comments sections made Bloomberg’s decision to do so easier. Comments sections are time-consuming and expensive to moderate; if publishers can point to other companies as justification, killing the comments becomes that much easier.

Publishers who kill the comments like to point out that, with news brands and journalists available on a myriad of social platforms, readers aren’t exactly at a loss for ways to get in touch. Indeed, in the Tablet announcement, Newhouse says readers who don’t want to pay to comment should feel free to usual social media or email to engage with the magazine.

Response to the move on Twitter has been split between those excited about a new approach to comments and those worried about decreased quality, loss of equal access, and the price of commenting privileges — a relatively reasonable $2 a day or a whopping $180 a year:

When you get over the shock of hearing it, I don’t think asking people to pay for commenting is a bad idea http://t.co/brMVLBAZNq

— Daniel Victor (@bydanielvictor) February 9, 2015

https://twitter.com/marcatracy/status/564864148992176132

https://twitter.com/glichfield/status/564873107681202176

What a great way to shut down comments: by CHARGING FOR THE RIGHT TO COMMENT. http://t.co/vuaWj047Rq

— whit (@whitneyarner) February 9, 2015

https://twitter.com/ngjenkins/status/564869174464241664

The system appears to still have some kinks; Newhouse’s post announcing the change says it has zero comments in one place on the page and nine comments in another. And if you pay your two bucks to see what’s there, you currently see only one comment, perhaps the web’s most familiar comment:

Killing the comments is a different matter for general news sites that don’t rely on community engagement for reader loyalty and revenue. But for other sites, the comments are much more valuable. Gawker, for example, simply wouldn’t be Gawker without the Kinja commenting platform. Tablet sees itself in this category of publisher; the comments are worth saving for the benefit of engaged readership, but can’t be left completely open to the tyranny of the crowd.

“Like a lot of other sites, we’re just looking for ways to make the discussions around our articles more thoughtful,” says Newhouse. “This seemed worth a shot.”

https://twitter.com/alananewhouse/status/564894592949309440