Nieman Foundation at Harvard
HOME
          
LATEST STORY
How can we reach beyond the local news choir? Spotlight PA’s founding editor has ideas
ABOUT                    SUBSCRIBE
Feb. 25, 2025, 9:09 a.m.
Reporting & Production

Student press freedom isn’t universal

Student journalists outside the U.S. navigate restrictions without First Amendment protections.

This piece was originally published in The Nutgraf, a weekly newsletter on student journalism from Chatwan Mongkol.

We’re happy to begin sharing some of the best original reporting on student journalism with Nieman Lab readers. In recent years, student journalism has prompted a president’s resignation, a federal civil rights lawsuit, and the firing of a high-profile football coach. Widespread protests and campus encampments thrust college journalists into national spotlights. But, as Mongkol notes, “the majority in the spotlight are from big-name journalism schools. Other papers are making an impact and driving the conversation in their own communities too.” Student journalists are also stepping up to fill in gaps in local and statehouse news across the country.

Student Press Freedom Day is Feb. 27 in the United States. But here in Korea — and in much of the world — it is just another Thursday.

In Korea, awareness of student press freedom remains minimal, even nationally.

In the professional sphere, while the Korean Constitution guarantees freedom of speech, press organizations often face defamation lawsuits or other repercussions.

For example, news outlets that reported on former President Yoon Suk Yeol’s defamatory language were later banned from accompanying him on business trips. In the first year and a half of his administration, Yoon’s government filed 11 defamation cases.

From 2022 to 2024, South Korea’s press freedom ranking dropped from No. 43 to No. 62.

For student journalists, the clampdown on press freedom is harsher.

Unlike in the U.S., where the New Voices movement and organizations like the Student Press Law Center advocate for student press rights, Korea’s student journalism, especially in middle and high schools, remains largely confined to print publications within individual schools.

As a result, Korean student journalists must take extra precautions. This often means self-censoring topics that might not sit well with the administration and consulting advisers on what is safe to publish.

International school journalists have it harder, especially for our non-Korean staff. South Korean immigration law prohibits foreigners from engaging in political activities, limiting coverage opportunities such as protests.

At my school, the administration previously turned down sensitive Jets Flyover article topics and reviewed articles before publication to protect us from lawsuits.

For instance, they turned down an article on teachers’ rights in the public school system, as it was pitched shortly after an elementary school teacher died by suicide due to harassment from parents.

However, in the past few months, we’ve moved away from prior reviews.

As we’ve gained more experience, we’ve learned to navigate the fine line between slander and responsible journalism, ensuring we cover important topics in a timely yet respectful manner.

For example, we’ve been able to tackle sensitive local news stories, such as deepfake sex crimes in South Korea.

We also make a point to triple-check our work for bias.

For opinion pieces, we use the Concession-Refutation model, acknowledging opposing viewpoints before making our case.

In an article critiquing the prevalence of electric vehicles in South Korea, the writer first addressed the environmental benefits of EVs before presenting a well-supported counterargument.

At other international schools, students have found ways to navigate press freedom without First Amendment protections.

At the American School in London, for example, student journalists adapted resources from the Student Press Law Center and local laws to create a press freedom contract, which their high school principal signed.

Here in Korea, student press freedom is what we strive toward as a publication. But it is also a fine line we must not cross for our own safety.

As a high school student journalist, you can — and should — advocate for student press freedom, too.

Spread the word that student journalism fills gaps in local media coverage. And remember: Student voices have the power to create real change in their communities.

Leanne Yoon is a high school student journalist, editor-in-chief of the Jets Flyover at South Korea’s Daegu International School, and founder of High School Press Central.

Photo via Adobe Stock

POSTED     Feb. 25, 2025, 9:09 a.m.
SEE MORE ON Reporting & Production
Show tags
 
Join the 60,000 who get the freshest future-of-journalism news in our daily email.
How can we reach beyond the local news choir? Spotlight PA’s founding editor has ideas
In the wake of the 2024 election, where “democracy” was not a top issue for most voters, local news messaging focused on democracy may not suffice to build the broad coalition essential to give local news in the U.S. a sustainable future.
Robert W. McChesney, America’s leading left-wing critic of corporate media, has died
After studying the early days of radio, McChesney developed a holistic critique of media structures that exposed how open they were to manipulation by those in power.
“Some hard and important lessons”: One of the most promising local news nonprofits looks back — and ahead
The National Trust for Local News is a nonprofit organization with a mission so important even its harshest critics want it to succeed.