In October 2007, The New York Times ran a story about an unusual new news startup named — at least according to the Times copy desk — “Pro Publica.”
“The plan is to do long-term projects, uncovering misdeeds in government, business and organizations,” Richard Pérez-Peña wrote. “Nothing quite like it has been attempted, and despite having a lot going for it, Pro Publica will be something of an experiment, inventing its practices by trial and error. It remains to be seen how well it can attract talent and win the cooperation of the mainstream media.”
Nearly 20 years later, ProPublica is as remarkable a success story as we’ve seen in digital journalism. After launching with about 20 staffers, it expects to hit 250 this year. And one of its most remarkable transitions during that time is its growing interest in local news. What was once resolutely an Acela-corridor newsroom now has reporters in 20 states, plus structured partnerships with more than 20 local newsrooms, from Anchorage to Tucson, Tulsa to Burlington.
The site’s latest expansion is to California. In May, it announced a new California “investigative reporting hub” — ProPublica’s sixth — and it just named Bernice Yeung to run it. The longtime ProPublican who oversees its local initiatives is Charles Ornstein. He’s spent the past decade building its local work from a single site in Illinois to something that — with California now covered — very nearly covers the entire Lower 48. I spoke with Ornstein about the new operation out west, how ProPublica thinks about its increasingly scattered newsroom, and how it focuses on making local stories resonate nationally. Here’s a lightly edited transcript of our conversation.
And more than that, I think, so many of the big issues that are going to face our country, from water policy to climate change to agricultural policy, they have a core centering in California. So as we looked at it, it felt really, really obvious that if we were going to expand to one place now, California needed to be that place.
There’s been a lot of changes to the California news ecosystem. Obviously, you know, the retrenchment that’s happened at the L.A. Times, which is very personal to me, having worked there. [Ornstein was a reporter for the L.A. Times from 2001 to 2008.] Some cutbacks in public radio as well.
But there’s also growth that’s taken place, from a revitalization of the San Francisco Chronicle, to CalMatters, to even new outlets like L.A. Material and LA Local. The local news ecosystem in California has changed a lot. I think the premium has gone to covering California in a more micro way, in a more community way or neighborhood way, as LA Local demonstrates, or The San Francisco Standard, for example.
But I think we felt like nobody’s covering California the way we want to cover California. Specifically, to write in a way that is relevant to California audiences, but for every story to also think about: How does this resonate for a non-California audience? I think the California news outlets that do a great job are primarily writing for a California audience. That’s their audience, that’s their subscriber base. So their main focus is writing for that audience. I think as we think about local stories overall, we want to be sure that they that they both address local needs, but also really help a reader who, you know, doesn’t live in California, may never have visited California.
So just as an example, Rich Webster, who’s at Verite News [a Local Reporting Network partner], has been writing about the governor and his approach at being “tough on crime,” and what that actually means. You know, during the first Trump administration, there was an effort, with the First Step Act, to be less punitive to people and give them a second chance. And the governor of Louisiana has taken a very, very different view, which is, you know, “we need to be even harder than ever on these folks.”
So what does that represent? What does that signify for other states? Does it actually work? What are the costs of doing this? Like, this is a question that’s important in Louisiana, but it’s a question that’s important everywhere, because politicians elsewhere may look to Louisiana as a model. And so it isn’t just a Louisiana story.
Similarly, a few years back, we wrote about what happened after the Road Home Project in Louisiana — a story that was about recovery after Katrina, but it’s also about, you know, recovery and disaster response and what we do after disasters. And in an era where we’re facing increasing disasters, that’s the story that mattered beyond Louisiana. So I do think every time we do a local story, whether it’s through the LRN or through our local offices, one of the first questions we ask is: Why would a reader who doesn’t live here care?
Almost everybody who was on staff lived in New York. It was a requirement, you didn’t have a choice — you had to move to New York. We had a couple people in D.C. But for the most part, the belief was we all needed to be in one place and that place needed to be the hub of the media ecosystem.
A few things changed. The dramatic implosion of the local news landscape gets more pronounced with every passing year. It became really hard to ignore that. Once ProPublica had demonstrated that it was both journalistically successful and philanthropically successful, we had a role to play. We can’t solve all local journalism issues, but we can play a role in ensuring that communities have access to accountability journalism where they live. And then I think with Trump’s first election in 2016, it became painfully clear to the media broadly that you can’t just look at the world primarily from the coasts.
So in late 2016, we announced the start of ProPublica Illinois. In 2017, we announced the start of the Local Reporting Network. That was really our first effort to say we have a role to play in this ecosystem. So fast forward to now, and we have 21 active partnerships through the Local Reporting Network. And with the addition of California, we will have 33 reporters on staff in 20 states who are covering local issues. And the reason that’s important, from my perspective, is that these are people who are sending their kids to school in those states. They’re worshiping in those states. They’re going to the grocery store in those states. They’re watching political ads in those states. They understand those states — they’re not parachuting into them. And I think that that gives us real visibility into what’s going on in lots and lots of different places.When we did a big expansion in 2021 and they became our Midwest newsroom, we realized it didn’t make sense for everybody to have one of everything — that ProPublica benefited from the scale of ProPublica. So the newsrooms no longer had their own brand and had to maintain their own website and their own social channels. We thought it was beneficial to just have a single source. And I think that’s worked out really well.
And then with the fundraising, I think we initially felt that you could build a robust enough local fundraising base to support the Illinois operation and other operations. I think we’ve come to realize there is a lot of support for local journalism nationally, but that it’s somewhat uneven in local jurisdictions. Funders are very interested in what is going on locally, and not necessarily in their own jurisdictions. ProPublica has more than 80,000 individual donors. We hear from those folks all the time that they care a lot about what’s happening in local journalism. But it’s not so much in their neighborhood per se — it’s just overall. And so I think having a fuller, more robust set of hubs has helped us fundraise for the organization broadly, but we don’t fundraise with the expectation that every hub will raise enough money locally to pay for itself.
We worked for many years with Molly Parker, who’s based in Carbondale, Illinois. My view on this was: Carbondale, Illinois needs Molly Parker. How do we ensure they can keep Molly Parker? And that involves supporting Molly Parker to be in that community. And we see this over and over again — Kyle Hopkins in Anchorage, who has done unbelievably important work covering Alaska. Alaska needs Kyle.
Part of working in this area and local journalism specifically is that you don’t know how the local ecosystem is going to change. And I think part of our role will be in response to what happens. But I also think we’re not just waiting for things to happen to do things on our own. We have a lot of exciting initiatives underway, and I think the key is to execute on them.


